IHG Adds Kimpton to Portfolio with Holiday Inn and Crowne Plaza

kimpton_holiday
IHG says Kimpton’s deeply personal experience won’t change. But Kimpton’s loyal guests aren’t buying it. We aren’t either.

Intercontinental Hotel Group, a pioneer in hotel standardization with 4,700 Holiday Inns, Candlewood Suites, and other brands worldwide, announced the acquisition of beloved boutique hotel collection Kimpton Hotels for a cool $430 million cash.

IHG CEO Richard Solomons, reached on his way to Davos for the World Economic Forum, told Bloomberg News the acquisition of Kimpton’s 62 boutique hotels was necessary for IHG because “we just couldn’t replicate it.”

They’d already tried, with the 2004 launch of the mass-produced boutique hotel chain, Indigo.

Solomons says, “The culture and values of both companies are well aligned.” Let’s take a quick look at those values.

IHG corporate goal: “Our strategy is to build the hotel industry’s strongest operating system focused on the biggest markets and segments where scale really counts.”

Kimpton corporate goal: “We believe that human, heartfelt connections are what make life worth living.”

IHG loyalty program: IHG Rewards Club lists among its member perks, “collect points, points never expire, no blackout dates, complimentary weekday newspaper.”

Kimpton loyalty program: Karma Benefits includes—for now—Raid the Bar (exactly what it sounds like, no $11 potato chips), birthday offer, $30 in-room spa credit, and custom stay preferences.

These benefits translated into a fiercely loyal following of travelers who felt recognized, because they truly were. A friend who is a frequent Kimpton guest finds a Heineken and a plate of chocolate-chip cookies whenever he checks into a Kimpton. And Karma members get free WiFi just for signing up. Other innovative benefits included an invitation to dinner with Kimpton’s CEO. 

Will the goldfish stay or go?
Will the goldfish stay or go?

I can’t imagine the Heineken and cookies will survive an integration into IHG’s rewards program, or that Richard Solomons will skip Davos for dinner with my friend. Other distinctive and charming aspects of Kimpton hotels will need to be watered down—or will disappear altogether—so that the hotels can fall into the IHG production line, that “operating system focused on the biggest markets and segments where scale really counts.”

Kimpton’s 71 destination restaurants were a big part of the draw for IHG, and one of the distinctive elements unlikely to survive the scale-up. Big chains make money by leveraging supply chain efficiencies. If Kimpton’s restaurants have to order meat from a large, national supplier instead of local, farm-raised products chosen by the chef, are the chefs, known for their neighborhood connections and passion for innovation, going to be able to create destination-worthy food?

It’s like your favorite steakhouse was just purchased by Outback. 

So who’s happy? Analysts. The hotel sector is down overall, but the market is bullish on IHG this morning (stock falls after acquisition announcements in more than 50% of cases; IHG is up). The next press announcement from IHG will be their plans to roll out Kimpton Hotels across the globe.

Solomons says that with Kimpton’s CEO and COO staying on, the deeply personal experience won’t change. But Kimpton’s loyal guests aren’t buying it. The boutique brand’s social media crew is working overtime reassuring loyal followers, many of whom feel overlooked, or flat-out dumped:

Screen Shot 2014-12-16 at 1.04.34 PM

In good news for real boutique hotel lovers: San Francisco’s Serrano Hotel, once part of Kimpton, just joined Stash. That means travelers can earn points for free nights without having to watch their favorite boutique hotel implement standardization: Jasper’s Corner Tap and Kitchen will still serve Arrogant Bastard on tap, instead of beer from whatever large company scores the IHG/Kimpton contract.

8 thoughts on “IHG Adds Kimpton to Portfolio with Holiday Inn and Crowne Plaza

  1. I have to say I agree with you. While this was a very smart move by IHG it does comes with the duilution of a much loved brand. In a perfect world Kimpton would just use the resources IHG comes with (capital, leverage, development expertise) and step aside, but we all know that won’t happen. Thanks for the input!

  2. I am so afraid that Kimpton Hotels will lose their unique charm…although this may trim costs, they are totally worth the money.

  3. The goldfish and backpack for my grandson was the driving engine for the last two reservations; I will now have to evaluate other hotels

  4. Very disappointing news . I have been a regular at Nine Zero in Boston since it opened and stay several times each year. There is usually some wine, fruit and cheese in the room for my arrival. Can’t see that continuing.
    I guess it’s time to look elsewhere……The Charles St Hotel perhaps…….

    1. Hi Alan, if you’re looking in Boston, check out the Lenox or the Verb so you can earn points for free stays. Also, The Hotel Veritas in Cambridge is just around the corner from The Charles and is also a Stash partner.

  5. Admittedly, I don’t have a horse in this race. But, how does the IHG positioning of its loyalty program (as paraphrased above) differ from Stash? From Stash Rewards website main page: “Fast: Earn free nights quickly – points add up fast … Flexible: No blackouts or category restrictions & your points never expire”

    Seems you’re jumping to a lot of conclusions before anything has actually happened yet…which makes sense from a marketing perspective, I suppose.

    1. Sean, thanks for your comment. Our intention with this post was not to compare IHG’s loyalty program to Stash. Instead, it was to highlight the big difference in operating approaches of Kimpton and IHG and to question whether Kimpton’s success in building great guest experiences will survive under IHG’s large chain management. We admire Kimpton Hotels, as peers, for their free spirit and exceptional focus on each guest, and we sincerely hope they keep their personal touch.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s